Blog
Moissanite Jewelry: Selling Sunset Drama, Rapper Bling, and the $169 Ring That Had Everyone Talking
Los Angeles, Beverly Hills. The Netflix cameras were pointed at Mary Fitzgerald’s finger.
The stone was so bright under the lights it almost hurt to look at. Her French boyfriend Romain had gotten down on one knee with a moissanite ring. On camera, Mary’s face was all surprise. Off camera, a season-long war was brewing.
Because Davina — the one with a mouth faster than her brain — said it right in front of everyone: “Wait, that’s not a diamond. That’s moissanite.”
Romain’s face went green on the spot. He remembered that comment for the entire season.
“Can You Stop Checking Wikipedia?”
If you haven’t watched Selling Sunset — the short version is, it’s one of Netflix’s messiest real estate reality shows. A bunch of women in high heels sell multi-million dollar mansions in LA, and spend the rest of the time tearing each other apart.
One of the juiciest gossip lines from Season 2: Mary and her much-younger French boyfriend Romain got engaged. He was 13 years younger than her, and everyone initially thought he was a deadbeat. But he proposed. He pulled out a ring.
Then Davina leaned in, examined it, and said straight out: “That’s moissanite, right?”
Awkward silence.
Moissanite was known as the affordable alternative to diamonds — a fraction of the price, nearly identical to the naked eye. What Davina meant was clear: your man wouldn’t splash out on a real diamond. What Romain meant was: you’re not invited to the wedding.
That grudge lasted the entire season. Davina tried to apologize. Romain wouldn’t have it. She tried to explain. He got even angrier. In the end, he really did not invite her to the wedding.
Mary later posted a photo on Instagram with a new ring — this time a real diamond. The caption read: “Finally got my diamond, @themayavander you don’t have to look up what moissanite is on Wikipedia anymore!”
That post blew up. Some people sided with Romain — Davina was being unnecessarily cruel. Some sided with Davina — Romain was being petty. But more people were asking the same question: What the hell is moissanite? Is it worth all this drama?
Moissanite Is from Outer Space
I looked it up.
Moissanite isn’t a fake diamond. It’s not a piece of plastic. It’s a mineral called silicon carbide, discovered in 1893 by a French chemist named Henri Moissan in a meteor crater in Arizona — yes, literally a rock that fell from the sky, brought here by a meteor that crashed into Earth 50,000 years ago.
Natural moissanite is so rare it’s basically nonexistent. So scientists recreated it in labs. The difference from diamond? Diamond is pure carbon. Moissanite is silicon carbide. Diamond is a 10 on the Mohs hardness scale. Moissanite is 9.25 — the second hardest thing on Earth. And moissanite’s fire is more than double diamond’s — it throws off rainbow-colored sparkles under light, way flashier than diamond.
So the ring Romain bought wasn’t a “fake diamond.” It was a different stone altogether. It just happens to look like one.
But once Davina said those words, in the minds of Selling Sunset viewers, moissanite was branded forever: the poor man’s diamond.
Hip-Hop’s “I’ll Take It” Moment
But here’s where it gets interesting. Another crowd sees it completely differently.
In the American hip-hop scene, moissanite has long stopped being a “settling” word. New York-based brand IceCartel makes moissanite chains and watches, claiming over a million customers. A-list names including Rick Ross, Fivio Foreign, Rubi Rose, Rich The Kid, and Trippie Redd have all worn their pieces.
You read that right. Rick Ross — the guy whose jewelry could buy a house — wears moissanite.
And Quavo, from Migos, has been spotted multiple times with moissanite “iced-out” watches, paired with chains, rings, and custom grills. Even if you don’t listen to rap, you’ve probably seen names like Gunna, Young Thug, and Blueface in gossip columns — all appearing on the fan list of moissanite watches.
The reason is simple: on stage, in music videos, under the spotlight — moissanite is flashier than diamond. Higher dispersion, more colored sparkle. The camera picks it up, and the audience just sees a screen full of bling. Who cares what it’s made of? A full-diamond Rolex might run you several hundred thousand dollars. A moissanite “iced-out” watch costs a few thousand and looks even better on camera.
The hip-hop logic has never been “I bought the most expensive.” It’s always been “I look like I bought the most expensive.”
That Girl Who Got Shamed at a Party
But ordinary people don’t have the confidence of hip-hop stars.
In 2024, New York fashion blogger Kelsey Kotzur posted a TikTok that went viral. In the video, she said she was at an event when a stranger walked up to her, complimented her ring — “It’s so beautiful, it must have cost a fortune.” Kelsey said: “It’s not expensive. It’s moissanite. Pretty affordable.”
The woman’s expression shifted instantly. Cold. She threw out a dismissive “Oh, so it’s fake” and walked away.
Kelsey fired back on camera: “It’s a DIFFERENT STONE! Could you tell the difference? You thought it was beautiful two seconds ago!”
The video racked up over 127,000 likes. The comments section went off. Some said “I only wear real diamonds.” Others said “I love my moissanite ring — I don’t get why everyone’s so obsessed with diamonds.” And some went straight for the stranger: “She couldn’t tell the difference but still wanted to act superior.”
Kelsey followed up with a one-line mic drop: “If moissanite has one fan, it’s me.”
So Who’s Right?
Davina from Selling Sunset thinks moissanite isn’t good enough. Rick Ross in hip-hop wears moissanite chains in music videos. Kelsey in New York got shamed by a stranger at a party.
Same stone. Three completely different reactions.
Davina cares about “is it a diamond” — her standard is exclusive and absolute. Rick Ross cares about “is it flashy enough” — his standard is visual impact. Kelsey cares about “this is what I chose” — her standard is personal choice.
Who’s right? No one. But the numbers tell a story.
In 2024, over 61% of newlywed American couples chose lab-grown diamonds or alternative stones for their engagement rings — a 239% increase from 2020. Reality TV stars in Beverly Hills were fighting over moissanite, but actual Beverly Hills consumers were quietly buying it. In 2025, among the “big diamond” rings posted by Western influencers, many were actually moissanite. Sales of moissanite on AliExpress increased 20 times.
Davina might not have known it when she was mocking Romain on camera — a few years later, the people making fun of moissanite would become the minority.
One Last Thing
Romain later saved up and swapped Mary’s ring for a real diamond. Davina didn’t get invited to the wedding. That “you don’t have to check Wikipedia anymore” Instagram post became one of Selling Sunset‘s all-time greatest clapbacks.
But here’s how the story actually ended: Mary and Romain are still together. Davina is still on the show. And moissanite is still being bought by more and more people.
Some stones are diamonds. Some are moissanite. Some people spend three months’ salary on their engagement rings. Some people spend $300. At the end of the day, everyone’s living the same life — taking the ring off after a shower, leaving it on the bathroom counter, forgetting to put it back on, walking out the door.
How much your marriage is worth has nothing to do with the price tag on your finger.
Afterword: Kelsey later added in another video: “When she complimented my ring, she didn’t know it was moissanite. The moment I told her, she didn’t like it anymore. That means she never actually liked the ring — she only liked the word ‘diamond.'” The top comment on that video read: “She didn’t change. The ring didn’t change. The only thing that changed was the label in her head.”
